Abstract
Purpose: Musculoskeletal pain has been associated with work stress and a shortened career in the dental hygiene profession. The purpose of this study was to determine if participating in two yoga sessions per week would reduce the musculoskeletal pain reported by dental hygiene students and or impact body composition.
Methods: A convenience sample of 77 dental hygiene students self-selected into treatment (yoga) and control groups. Students in the yoga group participated in bi-weekly, 60-minute yoga sessions for 13 consecutive weeks. Students completed a questionnaire and a Comparative Pain Scale evaluation prior to and immediately following the study period to assess musculoskeletal pain. Additionally, the Omron HBF-514C Full Body Composition Sensing Monitor and Scale was used to measure body mass index (BMI), body fat, and muscle prior to and upon completion of the study. Paired sample t-tests and independent t-tests were used to analyze the data.
Results: Thirty-eight dental hygiene students, with an average age of 23.9 years, participated in the yoga group and 39 were assigned to the control group. The majority of the participants were Caucasian (63.6%) females (90.9%). Participants in both groups were of similar age, ethnicity, and had comparable pre-study Harich Comparative Pain Scale scores. After participating in the yoga sessions, the treatment group reported a significant decrease in musculoskeletal pain (p<0.001), while the control group reported no significant decrease in musculoskeletal pain (p=0.881). The yoga sessions did not significantly impact the BMI scores for the yoga treatment group (p=.984) or the control group (p=.901).
Conclusion: This research supports the practice of bi-weekly yoga sessions as beneficial in decreasing musculoskeletal pain in dental hygiene students. Yoga can be considered a viable complementary health approach to incorporate into student schedules as a means of increasing the health and longevity of a dental hygiene career.
- ergonomics
- chronic musculoskeletal pain
- complementary health
- yoga
- dental hygienists
- dental hygiene students
Introduction
Chronic musculoskeletal pain (CMSP) has been reported in numerous studies among practicing dental hygienists and dental hygiene students.1-8 The most common areas of reported pain include: neck, shoulder, upper and lower back, and wrist/hand.1-8 Causes of pain include: neck bending and twisting, repetitive motion, vibration, and static reach/grip.5 Many dental hygienists have reported reducing the number of hours they work, taking time off, considered changing careers,3,4,8 and have even left the profession entirely as a result of pain4. Dental hygienists have also reported needing assistance from other staff members and have been unable to finish patient treatment due to the pain in the workplace.4
Complementary Health Approaches to Reduce Pain
Utilization of Complementary Health Approaches (CHA) has increased in recent years, 2002 to 2012, in the general population.9 Examples of CHA include: acupuncture, Ayurveda, chiropractic care, non-vitamin/non-mineral dietary supplements, massage, meditation, and yoga.9 Dental hygienists have reported using CHA, including yoga, to manage and reduce their work-related pain. Dental hygienists who used CHA had higher career satisfaction, increased career longevity, improved overall health and well-being, and were able to work their desired number of hours.4 The prevalence of CMSP in dentists who regularly practiced yoga was reported to be less when compared to those who participated in other types of physical activity.10 The incidence of CMSP in dental hygiene students who practice yoga has not been reported in the literature.
Effects of Yoga on CMSP
Yoga is described as a combination of breathing exercises, physical postures, and meditation used to calm the nervous system and balance the body, mind, and spirit.9 Over 36 million Americans have reported practicing yoga in order to increase their flexibility, reduce stress, and to become more physically fit. Over 70% of yoga practitioners are women attending at least one class per week.11 Many yoga practitioners believe that yoga improves performance with other activities, and in gerneral feel that practicing it is beneficial for overall well-being. Yoga practitioners have reported improved balance, and greater physical and mental strength when compared to non-practitioners.11
Yoga studies have been conducted among the general population suffering from chronic neck pain. Studies have shown a significant reduction in neck pain when yoga was practiced at least once a week for 90 minutes at a minimum of 9 weeks. Individuals with neck pain were also asked to continue their yoga practice at home between sessions in order to enhance the benefits.12,13 Individuals who practiced yoga reported a higher body awareness, felt more relaxed, reduced their pain medications, and felt their lives had improved due a reduction in neck pain.13
In multiple yoga studies conducted in the general population with chronic low back pain, significant reductions in pain have been reported.14-22 Yoga has been shown to improve strength, flexibility, balance, and posture in the general population.17,20,22 In addition to pain reduction, the practice of yoga has also been shown to reduce stress, depression, and improve mental well-being.14,15,20,21 Most studies show a significant reduction in back pain when yoga is practiced at least once a week14-19 for a minimum of four weeks.14 Sustained improvement in back pain has been reported from a period of six months14,18 to as long as 12 months.19
CMSP is frequently reported by practicing dental hygienists and dental hygiene students.1-8 CMSP has caused dental hygienists to reduce the number of hours they work3,4,8 and even leave the profession.4 Research shows that pain can begin early while still in dental hygiene school.1,2,5-7 Dental hygienists have reported practicing yoga to reduce and manage their pain,4 and yoga has been shown to reduce pain among the general population.12-22 The purpose of this study was to determine if participating in two yoga sessions per week would impact the musculoskeletal pain reported by dental hygiene students and, or, impact body composition.
Methods and Materials
Dental hygiene students enrolled in two universities, Minnesota State University, Mankato, Minnesota and West Coast University, Anaheim, California, participated in this study. Human subject approval was obtained from the respective Institutional Review Boards, and informed consent was obtained from all participants. A convenience sample of 83 students participated in this study, however, six participants were omitted during the data analysis due to incomplete survey responses, resulting in a sample size of 77 students (N=77).
Participation in this 13-week study was voluntary and students could withdraw at any time. Data was collected over a two-year period, with 35 participants in year one, and 47 participants in year two. Students volunteered to participate in two Vinyasa flow yoga sessions per week, for one hour per session, and were assigned to the test group (n=38), the remaining participants were assigned to the control group (n=39). Both groups were instructed to continue their normal routines regarding physical activity.
Data Collection
The students completed a survey that included a self-reported pain level prior to and immediately following the study to assess perceived musculoskeletal pain. The Harich Comparative Pain Scale, which combines pain level numbers of 0-10 with words and descriptions, was chosen in an effort to calibrate responses while maintaining brevity of the questionnaire. (Figure 1)
In order to examine the effect of yoga on body composition, heights were recorded for each participant, and the Omron HBF-514C Full Body Composition Sensing Monitor and Scale was used to measure weight, body mass index (BMI), body fat, and muscle prior to and upon completion of the study. Researchers have found measurements with the Omron scale to significantly correlate with BOD POD®, body composition results, (r=.95), albeit an overestimation of body fat.23 Paired sample t-tests and independent t-tests were used to analyze the quantitative data. A p-value <0.05 was used to determine statistical significant differences between the two groups.
Results
Demographics
Participants (N=77) ranged in age from 19 to 37 years, with an average age of 23.9 years. The majority of the participants were Caucasian (63.6%) females (90.9%). Table I includes the specific breakdown for race/ethnicity. Eighty-seven percent of participants were in their 1st year of dental hygiene. Of the 77 participants, 36 resided in Minnesota and 41 resided in California.
Frequency of Musculoskeletal Pain
A majority (92.2%) of all the participants reported having experienced musculoskeletal pain since beginning the dental hygiene program. Over half (55.8%) of all participants were experiencing musculoskeletal pain once a week or more and 51.9% of the participants reported experiencing more musculoskeletal pain as compared to before entry into the program (Table II).
Harich comparative pain scale
Race/ethnicity of participants (N=77)
At the time of the post-survey, 65.8% of participants in the yoga treatment group reported less musculoskeletal pain after participating in the study, compared to 7.7% of the control group. During the post-survey, 20.5% of participants in the control group reported more musculoskeletal pain as compared to only 2.5% of participants in the yoga treatment group. In separate questions specific to the yoga group, 71.8% felt their pain was somewhat to much better after participating in yoga, and 81.5% would participate in yoga again. In comparing yoga to previously used medication or other therapies to treat musculoskeletal pain, 57.9% of the treatment group preferred using yoga.
Frequency of Headaches/Migraines
Headaches or migraines are common with 84.4% all participants reported experiencing headaches or migraines since starting the dental hygiene program. Table II illustrates the headache/migraine frequency with 40.2% of all participants experiencing one or more episodes each week. Since starting the program, 46.1% of participants reported experiencing more headaches or migraines than before entering into the program. Similar to the reduction of musculoskeletal pain, 52.6% of participants in the yoga treatment group reported fewer headaches or migraines after participating in the study as compared to 7.7% of the control group.
Location of Pain
Participants identified current and previous levels of pain for various body areas, while also indicating if they have experienced pain during dental hygiene school (Table III). The most common areas of current pain reported on the pre-surveys include the lower back (40%) and the neck (37.7%), with the hip and upper arm/elbow the least commonly reported. The location of the pain experienced by students in the treatment and control groups, pre and post survey, is shown in Table IV.
Frequency of current pain on pre-survey
In the yoga treatment group, there was a decrease in number of participants reporting current pain in the post-survey for all body areas with the exception of the shoulder and upper arm/elbow. For the control group, there was an increase in number of participants reporting current pain in the post-survey for all body areas except for the hip. Paired sample t-tests were used to compare the number of participants who reported current pain in each body area between the pre- and post-surveys. Significantly fewer participants in the yoga group reported current pain in the lower back after completion of the study as compared to the pre-surveys (p<0.001). No other significant differences were found in the yoga group. The only significant difference reported in the control group was an increased number of participants reported pain in the lower arm on the post-survey as compared to the pre-survey (p=0.005).
Reported pain by location, current and prior to entry into Dental Hygiene (DHYG) Program (N=77)
Current pain specific to assigned group
Harich Comparative Pain Scale
In addition to reporting frequency and pain per body area, partici pants determined their overall level of musculoskeletal pain using the Harich Comparative Pain Scale. Pre-study participants (N=77) self-reported pain scores ranged from 0 to 5 (very distressing), with a mean score 1.88 (discomforting). Only 11.7% of the participants identified as having “no pain” on the Harich Comparative Pain Scale. Post-study participants (N=77) self-reported pain scores ranging from 0 to 5, with a mean score of 1.42 (between very mild and discomforting). Participants in the yoga group (n=38) and the control group (n=39) were similar in pre-study pain levels with no significant difference (p = 0.175) found using an independent t-test.
While both the treatment and control groups self-reported lower pain scores in the post-study as compared to pre-study surveys, a significant difference (p < 0.001) in scores was found using the paired sample t-test for the treatment group only (n=38). The paired sample t-test did not demonstrate a significant change in level of musculoskeletal pain reported before and after the research study (p= 0.586) for the control group (n=39). Specific results from the paired sample t-tests are shown in Table V. In order to further examine pain reduction, paired sample t-tests were used a second time excluding any participants who reported a pain level of 0 in the pre-study survey. Again, a significantly lower self-reported pain score (p < 0.001) was found in the treatment group (n=33), and was not significant (p=0.128) in the control group (n=38).
Body Composition
Heights were recorded for each participant prior to and upon completion of the study. The Omron HBF-514C Full Body Composition Sensing Monitor and Scale was used to measure weight, body mass index (BMI), body fat percentage, and muscle percentage (N=77). Pre-BMI scores ranged from 17.1 to 43.5, with a mean BMI of 23.8. Pre-body fat scores ranged from 13.8% to 53.5%, with a mean of 33.1%. Pre-muscle percentage scores ranged from 21.1% to 44.2%, with a mean of 28.6%. Paired sample t-tests were used to examine any differences in BMI, muscle percentage, and body fat percentage. For the control group (n=39), no significant differences were found in BMI (p=0.901), muscle percentage (p=0.274) or body fat percentage (p=580). There were also no significant differences in the yoga group for BMI (p=0.984), muscle (p=0.201), or fat (p=0.566).
Comparison of Harich comparative pain scores pre- and post-survey
Discussion
CMSP has been reported by practicing dental hygienists and dental hygiene students,1-8 and yoga has been shown to reduce chronic neck and low back pain among the general population.12-22 CMSP is a concern for the dental hygiene profession as practitioners have reported reducing their work hours, taking time off, considered changing careers,3,4,8 and have left the profession4 due to chronic pain issues.
In this study, dental hygiene students reported pain most frequently in the lower back (40%) and neck (37.7%) which is similar to previous studies where dental hygiene students reported pain in the neck and lower back most often,1,6 while practicing dental hygienists reported pain most frequently in the neck and shoulders.2,4,7,8 More than half (55.8%) of the student participants in this study reported experiencing pain once a week or more, which is similar to previous research findings.6,7 Most of the participants in this study who reported pain, were in their first year of the dental hygiene program (87.0%), which correlates with previous research.1
Dental hygiene students in the treatment group (65.8%) who practiced yoga twice a week for one hour per session reported significantly less pain when compared to the control group (7.7%). Likewise, dentists have reported less pain with a regular yoga practice.10 These findings are similar to the general population who reported less pain with a weekly yoga practice for 90 minutes in duration.12-22 The general population had a significant reduction in neck pain when yoga was practiced weekly for 9 weeks.12 A significant reduction in back pain has been reported after 12 weeks of practicing yoga,16,18,19,21 which is similar this study where dental hygiene students reported significantly less pain after 13 weeks.
Dental hygiene students reported increased pain (51.9%) since starting the program in this study, which is similar to previous research where students reported an increase in pain over a three-year span.1 Practicing dental hygienists have reported that CHA are acceptable for pain management and as an alternative to conventional medicine4 which is similar to these findings where dental hygiene students preferred yoga (57.9%) to treat their pain when compared to conventional medicine.
While this study primarily focused on musculoskeletal pain, information was collected regarding frequency of headaches and/or migraines, along with body composition. This study revealed that 40.2% of dental hygiene students are experiencing headaches/migraines at least 1-2 times each week. Headaches and migraines have a variety of predisposing factors including nutrition, changing sleep patterns, poor posture, stress, and secondary factors resulting from disease/illness.24 This study suggests that yoga may be useful in reducing the frequency of headaches/migraines with 52.6% of participants in the yoga treatment group reporting fewer headaches or migraines following the study as compared to 7.7% of the control group.
No significant differences were found in body composition between the pre and post-study statistics for either group. Many factors influence body composition including nutrition, aerobic exercise and strength training. The authors are not suggesting that yoga is ineffective in changing body composition, however this study was not designed to incorporate nutrition and strength training which could have impacted body composition. More research is needed to determine how regular yoga practice might influence body composition as well as headaches/migraine frequency in dental hygienists.
One limitation to this study was that students were not asked to practice yoga outside of the twice weekly scheduled sessions, while previous studies asked participants to practice at home in addition to the weekly scheduled session.12-16,18,19,22 Additional practice at home could have increased the amount of pain reduction. Another limitation was that the yoga instructors were not calibrated on the yoga poses taught to the students, although the particular style of yoga instruction was the same. Teaching a specific set of yoga poses may have created a different result. Yoga class attendance may have also influenced the overall amount of pain reduction. Some participants missed a weekly class session and were asked to make up the session at home with an assigned video. Having regularly scheduled make-up class with the instructor may have prevented the students from missing sessions during the study. In addition, a live class, as opposed to watching a video, is beneficial since the instructor is able to guide the participant into proper alignment and aids in injury prevention.
While yoga has been shown to reduce CMSP,12-22 there are some contraindications to performing specific poses depending on the location of pain that has been frequently reported by dental hygienists.1-8 Making the yoga instructor aware of previous injuries prior to the start of a class session is advisable so the instructor can guide the individualor modify the pose as needed. Individuals with a back injury should avoid or modify the following poses: bow pose; camel pose; cobra pose; corpse pose; fish pose; and upward facing dog.25 Individuals with a neck injury should avoid or modify: big toe pose; boat pose; bow pose; bridge pose; camel pose; cat pose; extended triangle pose; headstand; plow pose; and shoulder stand.26 Individuals with a shoulder injury should avoid or modify: dolphin; dolphin plank; handstand; side plank; arm balancing poses; and any pose with the arms extended upward.27 The following poses should be avoided or modified for individuals with carpal tunnel syndrome: cobra pose; crow pose; downward facing dog; plank pose; side plank pose; and upward facing dog.28
Future research should include studies on ergonomic and CSMP assessments in the clinical dental hygiene education setting and incorporation of yoga into the curriculum. Students could also be required to practice yoga independently, with hand-outs or videos, following the conclusion of formal class sessions with a follow-up assessment on prolonged pain reduction at six months post-study. This would be similar to previous studies assessing the long-term effects of a regular yoga practice six months following structured instruction sessions.14,19,21 A follow-up questionnaire after one year in clinical practice would be beneficial to assess pain levels and determine if dental hygienists continued to practice yoga after the initial exposure to yoga in dental hygiene school.
Conclusion
This study found that CMSP starts during the first year of dental hygiene school, and practicing yoga twice a week significantly reduced pain in a dental hygiene student population. Proper ergonomics should be reinforced in the clinical setting to prevent pain from occurring, and may also prolong the effects of a regular yoga practice. Students should be aware that CMSP has important implications for career longevity and incorporating yoga into the dental hygiene curriculum should be considered. Practicing dental hygienists may also benefit from yoga practice as part of their daily lifestyle.
Acknowledgements:
The authors thank PRN Dental Pros, LLC for the financial donation to hire a certified yoga instructor in Mankato, MN.
Footnotes
Angela L. Monson, RDH, PhD, is a professor and department chair in the Dental Hygiene Department at Minnesota State University, Mankato, MN; Aubreé M. Chismark, RDH, MS, is an associate professor in the dental hygiene department at West Coast University in Anaheim, CA and a Registered Yoga Teacher with the Yoga Alliance; Brigette R. Cooper, RDH, MS, is an associate professor and Trisha M. Krenik-Matejcek, RDH, MS, is an assistant professor; both are in the Dental Hygiene Department at Minnesota State University, Mankato, MN.
This manuscript supports the NDHRA priority area Professional development: Occupational Health (methods to reduce occupational stressors).
- Copyright © 2017 The American Dental Hygienists’ Association
